Russell Henley’s honesty cost him dearly. But you shouldn’t be surprised

Pro golf is contested on grounds so large but is so often adjudicated on instances so small. Take, for example, the 6-foot, 8-inch putt Tommy Fleetwood missed and the 5-foot, 8-inch putt Keegan Bradley made. The former may have hit a ball mark. The latter certainly didn’t. The Travelers Championship seemed to boil down to that. 

That, and the penalty Russell Henley called on himself Friday afternoon, across the property, out of sight from cameras and playing partners. Henley’s ball moved a fraction of an inch when it wasn’t supposed to, but it moved, and he believes he was the reason it did. 

Perhaps you caught the end of Henley’s week, where he needed birdie to give himself a chance to win the Travelers and miraculously holed out from greenside rough to make it happen. Bradley’s birdie putt was the only thing that kept him from a playoff, but it was a mid-week penalty he called on himself that garnered most of the headlines. 

While playing the par-3 8th on Friday, Henley tugged his approach left of the green. When he made his backswing on his second shot, the ball shifted ever so slightly from its original lie. It didn’t move far at all — “a dimple to the right” Henley said a day later — so little that he actually finished the swing, playing onto the green and making the putt for what seemed like a par. But he knew something didn’t feel right about it, so he called in a rules official. The stipulation here — Rule 9.2a — comes down to whether or not Henley was “virtually certain” that he was the reason the ball moved. Complicating it further was the fact that, according to Doug Ferguson of the Associated Press, the ruling official felt Henley should be able to play on without penalty. Only Henley viewed it otherwise. He was certain enough that he was the reason the ball moved, so he eliminated the grey area of a ruling, called a one-shot penalty on himself and moved on. 

News

Although the tournament did not move on without him. Henley shot 61 on Saturday to burst back into contention. He flirted with the lead throughout Sunday’s round, and ultimately found himself right in the thick of it down the stretch. When that 72nd-hole birdie chip went in, he had guaranteed himself at least a share of second, and a bunch of money — $1.76 million, to be exact — along with it. 

Just not a spot in a playoff. 

It would be easy for the golf fan at home to dwell on this instance. Or to feel validated in those feelings, even, by reading an article about it here on GOLF.com. But there’s a hidden lesson in the resoluteness Henley shared Saturday when he was asked about the situation. 

Ferguson was the reporter on hand to ask Henley for his explanation, and here’s what he received:

“I saw it fall to the right,” Henley said. “And so I know that for a fact. And right — when it happened it kind of shocked me a little bit, I still hit the shot, and as the ball was rolling on the green I was thinking, something just happened there. So I knew, I knew that the ball moved. I just felt it was the right thing to do. The rule says you have to be — I don’t know if it’s 19 out of 20 times or 95 percent — but definitely sure the ball moved. And I am. And so I just felt like it was the right thing to do.”

Henley admitted to being frustrated by making the ball move, but he was ultimately steadfast in how he had to respond, repeatedly calling it “part of the game.” And yet, the questions persist because, well, we’re human. Golfers of any variety have been in a similar situation where they’ll fluff a lie or accidentally cause a ball to move. Other pros have likely let what happened to Henley fly by, unannounced, and moved on without penalty. Henley just knows there are greater consequences that can sit with you as time goes by. 

There was the eight-shot penalty he called on himself when he used a second type of ball during a round in 2019. There was a junior tournament he played against Harris English when Henley accidentally stepped on his own ball and didn’t tell anyone, finishing second in a playoff. He remembers it well. Henley has called penalties on himself a few times, he said Saturday, mostly because golf is a weird game played in nature and weird things happen. That’s what the endless reaches of the Rule book and its decisions are for. And while they’re not easy to accept, it all goes back to that simple explanation he shared up top:

I just felt like it was the right thing to do. 

For those at home, wondering how that belief stacks up against finishing one penalty shot shy of a playoff, we can invoke what Henley said back in 2019. He was signing autographs after his second round when he realized he had accidentally played with a slightly different ball type, earning a penalty that kicked him well outside the cutline. It’s one of those infinitely small things that competitive golf is governed by, and Henley seems to understand better than most. 

He just isn’t interested in being made into some saint for doing so. As he told our own Michael Bamberger that week in 2019: “It’s unfortunate that playing by the rules is considered cool.”