Barath: As much as I agree with Josh’s take that Harmon was a compelling winner, I think the entire Saturday and Sunday of the U.S. Open were my favorite days watching golf all year. There was just so much going on among Rickie, Rory and Scheffler — along with the great play from the eventual winner, Wyndham Clark — that it was hard to look away.
Berhow: It’s hard to beat the U.S. Open at LACC. McIlroy charging and trying to end his major slump, and a fan favorite in Rickie Fowler trying to nab his first big one. Clark struggled a little down the stretch but finished it off with some grit. It was great TV.
3. According to Front Office Sports, NBC Sports plans to rotate multiple analysts in the coming months instead of hiring a single replacement for Paul Azinger, whose contract was not renewed. Brad Faxon, Justin Leonard, Kevin Kisner and Brandel Chamblee are among the names who have been rumored to get a shot in the chair. What are your thoughts on the “tryout”? And is there a front-runner here?
Sens: It seems odd to turn a job search into a public spectacle. I suppose it generates more chatter, but I’m not sure the upside outweighs the weirdness. Is this a search for the best candidate? Or a popularity contest? Isn’t this why there are screen tests? As for a front-runner, I think Chamblee is just about the smartest and most interesting commentator in golf. But I personally like him in the role he’s in— weighing in on a range of topics and often going deep on them. I’m not sure the lead analyst role in the tower lends itself as well to that. Word is Kevin Kisner can be very funny. That would be a welcome addition to a broadcast that is sorely lacking in humor.
Barath: I echo Josh in not really understanding the purpose of this exercise, especially considering that the general golf audience thrives on familiarity. Having a rotating cast of characters could really backfire for NBC and make for some uncomfortable situations on live TV since everyone has their own rhythm when calling these things. But on the other hand, it does give them the opportunity to get feedback — especially from social media — from an audience that tends to be pretty hard on those in the booth.
Berhow: Our James Colgan did a great job breaking all of this down here, but as he explains, this essentially gives the audience a chance to be in on the decision. It’s like American Idol. It seems like an odd decision to make it so public, but maybe that’s entirely the point. I think Faxon would be great here. Brandel might be too, but as Sens said, it’s hard to picture him doing something different than his current analyst role, which he does so well already.
4. For the first time in a decade, Q-School returned to offer a direct path to the PGA Tour. On Monday, five players picked up their Tour cards and 40 more earned Korn Ferry Tour status. Do you like the return of Q School sending players directly to the big show? Would you change anything?
Sens: Love the pressure and the stories that Q-School produces. Great to have it back. No changes here.
Barath: I’m happy to see it back and excited for all the storylines that it will produce in the future. Golf has historically been a meritocracy and Q-School is the greatest divider of those who show up when it really counts.
Berhow: For how confusing the Tour’s priority rankings, different statuses and playoff format can be for most fans, this is the kind of simplicity I love: finish in the top five and snag a Tour card. Great to have it back.
5. Happy holidays! What’s the best golf gift you ever received?
Sens: Scout’s honor, I’ve never received any gadgets or gear or apparel in my holiday stocking. But my wife routinely tells me: Don’t worry about dinner or the dishes or walking the dogs — go out and play some golf; I know you love it. To my mind, that’s the best kind of golf gift.
Barath: Like a lot of golfers, I tend to avoid any type of golfy gift since I have more than my fair share of goodies already, but one of the most thoughtful golf gifts I ever received was a set of Seamus headcovers made with County of Antrim tartan, which is where my grandfather was born in Ireland. They’re a simple reminder of where I come from and something I love.
Berhow: As odd as it sounds, a yard game named Yolf was one of the most important things I ever received. It was just a bunch of big targets you chip to in the yard, but it was enough to get me outside and practicing and enjoying the game. That’s how it all starts. My son is 3 so he’s not going to read this, but I’m hoping a Gator Golf he gets this year helps get him excited as well.
