What is Peyton Manning’s handicap? Exploring the two-time Super Bowl champion’s golf game

Tiger Woods and Peyton Manning on golf green

Peyton Manning played alongside Tiger Woods in the Pro-Am at the 2018 Memorial Tournament.

Getty Images

Peyton Manning is a household name in the United States because of his historic success on the football field, highlighted by two Super Bowl championships with two different teams. But this week, Manning will compete on live TV in a different sport, golf, when he joins Tiger Woods to face off against Tom Brady and Phil Mickelson in The Match: Champions for Charity.

When the star-studded match play event begins on Sunday, May 24, Manning will get to show off a golf game that is nothing to snuff at. Here’s a closer look at the NFL great’s performance on the course.

Peyton Manning’s golf handicap

According to GHIN, the official handicap system in the United States, Manning currently holds a handicap index of 6.4. That’s better than most recreational golfers, and it suggests he is fully capable of breaking 80, though he doesn’t necessarily do it all the time.

A review of Manning’s recent rounds confirms as much and also reveals a remarkable level of consistency in his results. Though he has posted no official scores for 2020, Manning entered 20 scores between May and September of last year. The six rounds he recorded in the month of September range from 82 to 88. But that lone 88 is the highest score on his GHIN page. His best score was a 78 in August at Cherry Hills.

Peyton Manning’s GHIN handicap card.

GHIN

According to the USGA, Manning would have a course handicap of 9 at Medalist (though he won’t be getting that many shots for the match against Brady and Mickelson), which is higher than his normal index due to the Florida course’s difficult course and slope ratings (73.1/141).

That shouldn’t be a problem since his partner Woods, winner of 15 major championships, calls Medalist home and has a course handicap of +8. Perhaps more importantly, his fellow non-PGA Tour opponent Brady has a Medalist course handicap of 11.

What golf clubs does Peyton Manning belong to?

There are three golf clubs that we are certain Manning belongs to, although in reality he likely is a card-carrying member at several different clubs.

He has two official home clubs, Castle Pines Golf Club in Castle Rock, Colo., and Cherry Hills Country Club in Cherry Hills Village, Colo. Cherry Hills is perhaps best known as the site of Arnold Palmer’s 1960 U.S. Open victory, the only U.S. Open win in Arnie’s career. The club also hosted Opens in 1938 and 1978, with the 1941 and 1985 PGA Championships also being contested on the 1922 William Flynn design.

Four Augusta National Golf Club photos

7 bizarre but true stories about Augusta National Golf Club, home of the Masters

By: Kevin Cunningham

But one club in Manning’s roster stands above all others, one of the most sought-after memberships in all of golf. Back in 2016, the future NFL Hall-of-Famer was invited to join Augusta National Golf Club, home of the Masters. Brady may belong to The Country Club and Seminole, but he certainly can’t top Manning’s Augusta trump card.

While he may know a thing or two about Augusta’s devilish greens, Manning’s past performance at Medalist is a warning sign for the match. In a video previewing the event, he admitted that he once played Medalist with Woods, but he struggled so much that on the 18th tee he had to beg his playing partner for a replacement golf ball.

“I was out of balls by the time I got to 18,” Manning said.

The Match: Champions for Charity will be televised live on Sunday, beginning at 3 p.m. ET on TNT.

Kevin Cunningham

Golf.com Editor

As managing producer for GOLF.com, Cunningham edits, writes and publishes stories on GOLF.com, and manages the brand’s e-newsletters, which reach more than 1.4 million subscribers each month. A former two-time intern, he also helps keep GOLF.com humming outside the news-breaking stories and service content provided by our reporters and writers, and works with the tech team in the development of new products and innovative ways to deliver an engaging site to our audience.