the 18th hole at the country club

At Brookline, golf faces an all-time debate. Distance? Or design?

The Country Club. Golf's Bomber Generation. This U.S. Open is going to be *good*.

Channing Benjamin

With history comes tradition — at least that’s the way it used to work on Championship golf courses.

But this year, there was nary an eagle on the 15th hole at Augusta National. In 2014, Pinehurst No. 2 — with no rough and the widest fairways on a Golden Age course in the modern history of the U.S. Open — clobbered everyone but winner Martin Kaymer.

What’s a golf fan to think? Times they are a-changing, yet many of us are still drawn to the thrill of the sport’s traditions. Each season, every one of the four majors has a role to play, and it would be a tragedy if, through the increasingly routine course tweaks now being made to “test” today’s Tour pros, they morphed into similar events.

Well, the site for this year’s U.S. Open — The Country Club, in Brookline, Mass. — will definitely be doing its part, reminding us how U.S. Open courses have historically been presented.

Eighteen holes already existed here prior to the advent of the game-changing rubber-wound-core Haskell ball in 1901. Ever since, the only constant at the oldest country club in America has been change, with more than 10 architects having worked on the course in its 129- year existence. And that is very much a part of its charm. This isn’t one architect’s 200th course. The Country Club has, in time, evolved into its own, fantastically inimitable thing, unified masterfully by a Gil Hanse restoration that began in 2007.

Interestingly, the exact configuration of holes for this year’s Open will be used for the first time. The USGA’s new routing — a combination of holes from TCC’s three nines — is compelling, with its artful mix of old-fashioned features and small greens and rough imperiling the sides and back of each putting surface. Players, consider yourselves on notice.

Overall, the greens nestle into their surrounds and are sloped either back-to-front or side-to-side. They’re tiny too.

Among current U.S. Open sites, only Pebble Beach features smaller targets. No doubt that some pros will jawbone about them, but Hanse has actually expanded the greens in size by 20 percent since the course hosted the Ryder Cup — the heated “Battle of Brookline” — in 1999.

Then there’s the wind. At the 1963 Open, it blew sufficiently to where, after 72 holes, the tournament’s three leaders sat at +9! (Julius Boros eventually won the playoff.) But wind isn’t essential for The Country Club to be a rigorous test. Under any scenario, relentlessly staying in position will be the task. Long over any green is not your friend, and gunning for back hole locations will be folly.

Case in point: The par-3 6th plays to a double plateau green, courtesy of Willie Campbell in 1894, that features a steep falloff left and to the rear. There’s no bunker behind the green to “save” the player from the prototypically nasty U.S. Open rough. Yes, it’s the largest green on the course, and, yes, Tour pros conjure all sorts of amazing up-and-downs most weeks. But this week will reward those with the discipline to resist flag hunting such “sucker” hole locations as front left, behind a yawning bunker, or back right, on the upper plateau. When Nick Faldo and Curtis Strange duked it out in the 1988 U.S. Open, they were masterful in staying below the hole as they tacked around the entire course.

the country club no 6
The double-tiered 6th hole will play all sorts of nasty come tournament week. Channing Benjamin

The blend of holes at The Country Club is bewitching. To miss the green on the steeply downhill, 131-yard 11th is to open Pandora’s Box. Even with a 60-degree wedge in hand, draw the wrong lie in the spinach and you risk sliding across the 17-yard-wide green. And if you think that first recovery shot is difficult, try the second one.

How players handle the 310-yard, par-4 5th will be fascinating. It plays uphill to a small green ringed by rough and bunkers. What will the pros, who commonly run roughshod over short two-shotters, do? Will a player be humble enough to hit, say, 6-iron off the tee? One thing he shouldn’t do is chase the perimeter hole locations recovered by Hanse. Miss those and you’ll go from being the hunter to the hunted.

Both the 5th and the par-3 11th will pit technology — and the golfer’s confidence that he can summon pretty much any shot — against small targets that resist aggressive approaches. This showdown of old versus new permeates the design. Think you can hold the 18th green with its fronting-cross bunker while playing out of five-inch-deep rough should you miss the fairway? Let’s hope not.

“Tour pros conjure all sorts of amazing up-and-downs most weeks. But this week will reward those with the discipline to resist flag hunting such “sucker” hole locations as front left, behind a yawning bunker, or backlight, on the upper plateau.”

Some daunting 4½-par holes best highlight the allure of the club’s rugged New England topography, specifically the 3rd and 10th, both 499-yard brutes. Both world-class holes weave past puddingstone ledges and intrusive shoulders from hillsides. Many other holes elbow in one direction or the other. It’s hard to believe players will hit driver on some of them, like the 373-yard, par-4 17th, which bends left, past four bunkers, to a slender and minuscule green. Other fairways feature bunkers 20 to 60 yards short of greens. Think they’re out of play? Miss a fairway and they become a factor, even for the world’s best. (Or brainiest. TCC is home to the Harvard golf team.) Getting up-and-in from 80 yards will be important, even if it isn’t glamorous.

Finally, only two par 5s exist, so no freebies this week! One of them, the 619-yard 14th, is among the hardest par 5s I’ve ever seen. It’s also one of golf ’s best relatively unknown holes, borrowed as it is from the club’s third nine, Primrose. Hitting the fairway is critical to stair stepping 30 feet to the next level of fairway with your second. Otherwise, be prepared for a blind 150-yard approach from the base of a hill to an angled green. Too many par 5s let golfers just slap the ball around. Not here.

The direction course design has taken in the 21st century is to be applauded. Fifty-yard-wide fairways and engaging greens framed by short grass — this provides ample challenge and plenty of fun for the greatest number of players. I love what it brings to the game. But for this one week, that won’t be the brand of golf on display.

I, for one, will be absolutely thrilled to see course discipline take center stage once again. The Country Club is a strict old schoolmaster, and few will get a passing grade at the 2022 U.S. Open. But reflecting back, the sport’s best may just become better, smarter golfers for the experience.

generic profile image