What it takes to win a U.S. Open at Winged Foot, according to two players who have done it

Geoff Ogilvy and Hale Irwin winning their U.S. Opens at Winged Foot

Geoff Ogilvy and Hale Irwin, the U.S. Open victors in 2006 and 1974, respectively.

getty images

This is the first installment in our five-part series, The Road to Winged Foot, powered by Cisco Webex, in which we’re highlighting how players, officials, broadcasters and others are preparing for the 2020 U.S. Open, set for next week at Winged Foot Golf Club in Mamaroneck, N.Y. First up: Two former Winged Foot Open champions reflect on what’s required to win the national championship on such a fearsome setup.

***

The most fun I ever had on a conference call came a week or so ago in a three-way conversation with two former U.S. Opens winners, Mr. Hale Irwin and Mr. Geoff Ogilvy.

You may be wondering about the use of the honorifics, and Hollywood-style at that. (On the first reference.) Well, in this bureau, in these holy days leading up to our great national championship, all former Open winners don Mister. While it is true that there is little in golf more pretentious than calling Ben Hogan Mr. Hogan, this week, under this byline, he is Mr. Hogan. Mr. Ben Hogan, first time out.

Hey, if win the U.S. Open four times, or even three times (Mr. Irwin, Mr. Tiger Woods) or two times (Mr. Andy North, Mr. Curtis Strange) or even once (Mr. Ogilvy), you’ll get the full treatment, too.

C’mon, Phil!

Mr. Irwin won his first U.S. Open (in 1974) on the same course where Mr. Ogilvy won his only (to date) U.S. Open. We all know where that was: the West Course of the Winged Foot Golf Club, in leafy Mamaroneck, N.Y. Mr. Ogilvy’s victory there came the last time the Open was played there, in 2006. Some people remember that Open best for the improbable 6 Phil made on the par-4 18th hole on Sunday. He would have won with a 4. A 5 would have meant an 18-hole Monday playoff with Mr. Ogilvy, who was in the house, watching Phil finish on TV. Alas, the double-bogey that lives in infamy and on a certain Callaway commercial.

But one of the wonderful things that came out of our session was a reminder of just how marvelously Mr. Ogilvy played, including the par he made on 18 in front of Phil, to get to the clubhouse at 285, five over par, and enjoy the feeling of being the leader in the house.

phil mickelson at 2016 U.S. Open

Returning to the scene of one of golf’s oddest episodes: Phil, Winged Foot, 2006

By: Michael Bamberger

“I’ve always loved par being important,” Mr. Ogilvy said. “It’s close to the most satisfying” thing there is in golf.

Five over!

That’s what the USGA is all about. That’s what the U.S. Open is all about. That’s why the U.S. Open is the U.S. Open. A.W. Tillinghast, the man who built Winged Foot, demanded golfers to stop iron approach shots on sloping greens.

As for Mr. Irwin, he called Winged Foot “the hardest course I ever played when weather wasn’t an issue.” He won at seven over. He described the foot-high rough in places.

“The moaning was unbelievable,” Mr. Irwin said. “Every shot was demanding.” He took 287 of them. “If I made a par, be very happy and move to the next hole.”

Mr. Ogilvy, born in 1977, has read about and watched the ’74 Open, what he called, as others have, “the Massacre at Winged Foot.” He recalled the 1984 U.S. Open at Winged Foot, when his countryman, Greg Norman, lost to Fuzzy Zoeller in a playoff.

As we spoke, it was Friday morning for Mr. Ogilvy in Melbourne, Australia, and Thursday night for Mr. Irwin, in Phoenix. They seemed to be enjoying each other’s virtual company, as members of this tiny club, of players who have won major championships at Winged Foot. Davis M. Love III won his PGA Championship in 1997 at Winged Foot. Had he taken two fewer strokes at the 1996 U.S. Open, we’d be trotting out a Mister for him right now. Instead, a nod to Mr. Steve Jones.

Mr. Irwin said something in the chat I had never considered before, despite many trips to Winged Foot. If you stood on each of the 18 greens at Winged Foot’s West Course, you’d think the course must be very hilly, because the greens have so much slope. But in actual fact, the course is quite flat. It’s the greens that make the course.

Mr. Irwin watched the 2006 U.S. Open on TV. He said in our interview that he liked Winged Foot better in 2006, because of its graduated rough, because of the condition of the course.

Dustin Johnson with Joe Buck.

What does it take to win a U.S. Open? We asked someone who knows about pressure

By: Michael Bamberger

Mr. Ogilvy was well aware of Mr. Irwin’s record as a U.S. Open player, as a golfer who was “tough as nails.”

Mr. Ogilvy said that his pitch to 18 “had my attention.” The fairway was short and tight he said it was like playing off a green. There was no margin for error. “My caddie said, ‘Let’s par the last four holes. Nobody else is going to do that.’” Mr. Ogilvy did, and the other contenders did not. The caddie was a legend of the European tour, Alister “Squirrel” Matheson.

When Mr. Ogilvy described his playing partner, Ian Poulter, dressed “head to toe in pink,” Mr. Irwin laughed. Mr. Irwin did not wear pink. In his U.S. Open prime, he was not one to do a lot of laughing. Mr. Zoeller was a joker. But you’re not going to find a lot of U.S. Open winners whose first move was to tell jokes.

Mr. Irwin compared how he played 18 on Sunday — driver and a 2-iron — with how Mr. Ogilvy played it, driver and a 9-iron. Dustin Johnson could surely play it this year with a driver and a wedge. But a 4 there will always be a good score. Of that both gents were sure.

generic profile image

Michael Bamberger

Golf.com

Michael Bamberger writes for GOLF Magazine and contributes to GOLF.com. He also participates in podcasts, primarily in tandem with Alan Shipnuck. Earlier in his career, he was a senior writer for Sports Illustrated for 23 years and a reporter on The Philadelphia Inquirer for nine years before that. He has written a half-dozen books about golf and other subjects. His magazine work has been featured in multiple editions of The Best American Sports Writing. He holds a U.S. patent on a utility golf club called the E-Club. In 2016, he was given the Donald Ross Award by the American Society of Golf Course Architects, the organization’s highest honor.