Top 10 best-selling putters of 2023 from Fairway Jockey

By: Marley Sims

December 12, 2023

6 golf putters arranged against a turquoise background

Any of 10 best-selling putters of 2023 at Fairway Jockey would be a great gift this season.

MARLEY SIMS

Welcome to Our Picks, where we fill you in on the newest and hottest golf equipment and accessories. Today we’re featuring the top 10 best-selling putters of 2023 at Fairway Jockey.

Last time, we featured nine favorite golf clubs our staff added to their bags this year, which you can read by tapping here.

By the way, if you purchase one of these clubs at Fairway Jockey, for a limited time, you’ll also get a free Pinned Golf Dart 2.0 Speaker and Prism Rangefinder with your purchase.

Fairway Jockey’s 10 top-selling putters this year

If you see a club (or a few) that catch your eye, you can purchase all of these clubs and customize them to perfectly fit you and your golf swing according to your specs.

To get the bet experience with your golf club, we always advise that you get fit by a professional to find your specs if you haven’t already. One of the best places to get fit is True Spec, where you can book an appointment and get fit by globally trusted professionals.

Scotty Cameron 2022 Phantom X 5.5 Custom Putter

Designed to promote a more flowing “blade-like” feel with the stability of a mallet, the milled sight line on the topline provides alignment, while the refined design aesthetic exudes high-end luxury and pristine craftsmanship at every turn.

Scotty Cameron 2022 Phantom X 5.5 Custom Putter

$429.99

The evolution of Scotty Cameron’s Phantom X 5.5 continues with his latest creation, inspired by Justin Thomas’ prototype gamer, yet refined with a new, self-centering sole plate design, updated graphics and an all-new Pistolero Plus grip with a decorative, non-slip texture. The small slant—or “jet” neck—configuration remains unchanged, as do the solid face and body precision milled from 303 stainless steel and integrated with an updated aluminum sole plate and customizable stainless steel sole weights. This combination of heavier steel and lighter aluminum moves weight to the perimeter of the head, increasing MOI, stability and forgiveness. Designed to promote a more flowing “blade-like” feel with the stability of a mallet, the milled sight line on the topline provides alignment, while the refined design aesthetic exudes high-end luxury and pristine craftsmanship at every turn. From the definitive misted surface textures designed to reduce glare, to the clean milling marks purposely designed, everything about the new Phantom X 5.5 instills confidence.

View Product

Scotty Cameron 2022 Phantom X 12 Custom Putter

An elongated face-to-flange sight line in dove gray guides the way, as the revamped, squared-up flange and sole design make alignment effortless and give the new 12 the appearance of a “longer” look.

Scotty Cameron 2022 Phantom X 12 Custom Putter

$429.99

Redesigned for 2022 with a new look from address and a refined, thinned out mid-section, the latest evolution of the Phantom X 12—the line’s high-MOI champion—has been updated for even more forgiveness, easier alignment and confidence-inspiring performance. Stability-enhancing weight is maintained in the 12’s swept-back stainless steel wings, while this mallet’s aesthetics and sonic properties have been updated with a re-designed precision milled 6061 aluminum face/core to deliver the ultimate in perimeter weighting. An elongated face-to-flange sight line in dove gray guides the way, as the revamped, squared-up flange and sole design make alignment effortless and give the new 12 the appearance of a “longer” look. With a misted texture and glare-cutting sheen, the anodized 6061 aluminum and 303 stainless components exhibit timeless craftsmanship in a modern configuration. Customizable stainless steel sole weights dial in the optimal putter length-to-weight ratio for a design that is among the most advanced face balanced high-MOI mallets to date. The new Phantom X 12 is also available in a left-handed model.

View Product

Ping PLD Milled Anser Custom Putter

This putter is milled to perfection from 303 forged stainless steel and custom-built to fit your game. A deep AMP face texture produces a Tour-preferred soft feel for precision and control.

Ping PLD Milled Anser Custom Putter

$449.99

The new PLD Milled line, which stands for Putting Lab Design, comprises four popular, tour-validated models to ensure a choice to match your stroke and eye. Each milled to perfection from 303 forged stainless steel and custom built to fit your game. A deep AMP face texture produces a tour-preferred soft feel for precision and control. MATERIALS Forged 303 Stainless Steel; fully machined Deep AMP (Aggressive Milling Pattern) face texture developed from TOUR player input.

View Product

Evnroll ER1.2 Tour Blade Putter

The Evnroll ER1.2 Tour Blade Putter is a traditional flange neck plumber blade. The ER1.2’s head is made from 303 stainless steel and is CNC milled in Carlsbad, Calif.

Evnroll ER1.2 Tour Blade Putter

$369.99

All Evnroll putters feature Sweet Face Technology which creates consistent distance on center and off-center hits. Evnroll accomplishes this by using precise patented face milling, which imparts progressively more energy transfer on off-center hits to roll the ball a consistent distance every time. The unique milling pattern also gears the ball back to your intended line. The Evnroll ER1.2 Tour Blade Putter is a traditional flange neck plumber blade. The ER1.2’s head is made from 303 stainless steel and is CNC milled in Carlsbad California. The Evnroll ER1.2 Tour Blade Putter Features: Head: 303 Stainless steel Color: Silver satin finish Swing weight: 35″ 355g • 34″ 370g • 33″ 370g Loft: 2° Lie angle: 70° Stock grip: Custom Evnroll red pistol grip Length: Measured from center of leading-edge to butt Balance: 35° toe down Shaft: FST stepless, .370″ tip Shafting: Straight shaft-mounted into an overfit plumber neck hosel Authorized Evnroll Retailer

View Product

Odyssey 2023 Tri-Hot 5K Double Wide DB Putter

Tri-Hot 5K putters transform the performance of a blade with multi-material front-loaded tungsten weighting that improves CG positioning while dramatically increasing inertia. This putter is equipped with two 25-gram adjustable weights.

Odyssey 2023 Tri-Hot 5K Double Wide DB Putter

$399.99

The Tri-Hot 5K Double Wide DB is a wide blade with minimal toe hang best suited for strokes with minimal arc and face rotation. Tri-Hot 5K putters transform the performance of a blade with multi-material front loaded tungsten weighting that improves CG positioning while dramatically increasing inertia. This putter is equipped with two 25 gram adjustable weights. HIGH PERFORMANCE AND TIGHT DISPERSION FROM STAINLESS STEEL FRONT Built to improve performance by reducing the amount of side spin on off-center hits, resulting in putts that are closer to the original line, with tighter dispersion, and a greater chance to go in on less-than-perfect strikes. We achieve this through a 303 stainless steel front section that includes the hosel and face area. The back section of these putters has been finish milled to exact shape and weight, helping to keep the CG forward. IMPROVED FORGIVENESS AND IMPROVED ROLL FROM TUNGSTEN FRONT WEIGHTS We’ve precisely positioned massive amounts of tungsten (up to 120 grams) behind the face in the toe and heel sections of the club head. The CG is moved forward for improved roll, while also increasing inertia to over 5,000 IZZ. It’s an improved level of performance that’s now available in new standard size mallets.

View Product

Ping 2023 Anser 2D Putter

Each Ping Anser model putter is individually designed to achieve the proper balance of feel and forgiveness in a confidence-inspiring look.

PING 2023 Anser 2D Putter

$279

A PEBAX insert with shallow milled surround ensures a softer feel and consistent ball speed with pleasing acoustics. Tungsten toe-heel weights provide stability and forgiveness, a single white alignment line contrasts with the all-black head, and a ball-width cavity floor help frame the ball to make aligning to the target easier.The new PING putters all have one thing in common – precision performance on putts of every distance. Everything else is different. From firmer milled faces to soft feeling inserts, simple alignment aids to eye-pleasing color blocking, high MOI blades to multi-material mallets, each model is individually designed to achieve the proper balance of feel and forgiveness in a confidence-inspiring look that leads to more consistency on the greens. With 10 models in all, they leverage the best of PING putters from the past and present with an eye on making more putts in the future. A MODEL TO FIT EVERY GOLFER Each model is individually designed to achieve the proper balance of feel and forgiveness in a confidence-inspiring look. Choose from high MOI blades and multi-material mallets. TECHNOLOGY YOU CAN FEEL From firm milled faces to soft feeling inserts, the line-up is engineered to match a variety of feel preferences and deliver the control and consistency on putts of every length. ALIGNED FOR ACCURACY Single alignment cues or multiple lines combine with eye-pleasing color blocking to match your eye for confidence where it matters most.

View Product

Ping 2023 Prime Tyne 4 Putter

The shallow-milled face delivers a firmer feel, consistent ball speed and pleasing acoustics. The color blocking utilizes a platinum topline contrasted against the black cavity to draw the focus forward.

PING 2023 Prime Tyne 4 Putter

$279

A top performer evolves for 2023, featuring the customary twin forks that make the head highly stable to ensure forgiveness and accuracy. The shallow milled face delivers a firmer feel, consistent ball speed and pleasing acoustics. New color blocking utilizes a platinum topline contrasted against the black cavity to draw the focus forward.The new PING putters all have one thing in common – precision performance on putts of every distance. Everything else is different. From firmer milled faces to soft feeling inserts, simple alignment aids to eye-pleasing color blocking, high MOI blades to multi-material mallets, each model is individually designed to achieve the proper balance of feel and forgiveness in a confidence-inspiring look that leads to more consistency on the greens. With 10 models in all, they leverage the best of PING putters from the past and present with an eye on making more putts in the future. A MODEL TO FIT EVERY GOLFER Each model is individually designed to achieve the proper balance of feel and forgiveness in a confidence-inspiring look. Choose from high MOI blades and multi-material mallets. TECHNOLOGY YOU CAN FEEL From firm milled faces to soft feeling inserts, the line-up is engineered to match a variety of feel preferences and deliver the control and consistency on putts of every length. ALIGNED FOR ACCURACY Single alignment cues or multiple lines combine with eye-pleasing color blocking to match your eye for confidence where it matters most.

View Product

TaylorMade 2023 Spider GTX Custom Putter

Made from lightweight 6061 Aluminum, the 194-gram top allows more weight to transfer to the outside of the frame, The back weight ring is made of heavy stainless steel – 154 grams, which creates a deeper CG for less face rotation and enhanced stability.

TaylorMade 2023 Spider GTX Custom Putter

$250 (was $350)

EXPANDING THE MODERN SHAPE OF STABILITY Spider GTX sets the standard for performance and construction. The GTX shape resembles the past Spider shapes with True Path and a new extreme back weighting for forgiveness. LIGHTWEIGHT ALUMINUM CAP Made from lightweight 6061 Aluminum, the 194 gram top allows more weight to transfer to the outside of the frame BACK WEIGHT STABILITY BAR The back weight ring is made of heavy stainless steel – 154 grams, that creates a deeper CG for less face rotation and enhanced stability. PURE ROLL2 INSERT The firmer co-molded insert, manufactured of black TPU urethane with silver aluminum beams at a 45° angle designed to improve topspin across the face. TRUE PATH ALIGNMENT The white space in the center of the putter helps frame the ball and creates a path to the hole.

View Product

Mizuno M CRAFT OMOI Type 2 Custom Putter

Available in three colors (black, blue and silver), the Mizuno M Craft is forged from premium 1025 carbon steel and CNC milled, using all the successful fundamentals of the original M-Craft models. These feature a heavier head weight to increase MOI for improved stability.

Mizuno M CRAFT OMOI Type II Custom Putter

$349.99

The new M.CRAFT OMOI introduces heavyweight stability to Mizuno’s forged putter line-up – renowned for its precise looks and feel.Forged from premium 1025 carbon steel and CNC milled, using all the successful fundamentals of the original M-Craft models, the OMOI putters feature a heavier head weight to increase MOI for improved stability.The OMOI achieved its new stability by taking a view of the entire club – balancing out the increased headweight with a lighter weight grip and shaft to shift the club’s CG and help control face rotation through the putting stroke.Every putter also comes with an additional weight kit – including a pair of 3g and 13g weights interchangeable with the 8g fitted as standard.OMOI 01 – Slant Neck Blade (60-degrees of toe hang, ¾ shaft offset)OMOI 02 – Plumber’s Neck Blade (40-degree of toe hang, full shaft offset)OMOI 03 – Full Mallet (Face Balanced, full shaft offset)

View Product

Odyssey Eleven Tour Lined S Custom Putter

This unique head shape delivers the outstanding MOI properties that you would expect from a mallet. However, this shape uniquely combines a more forward CG positioning that delivers the tight dispersion of a blade, for putts that stay on the right line. All these design characteristics are available in three proven options for better aim: a Tour Lined version, Triple Track Alignment, or a classic, unlined model. There’s an Eleven for everyone.

Odyssey Eleven Tour Lined S Custom Putter

$299.99

The Eleven Tour Lined S is a toe hang mallet best suited for golfers with strokes with moderate face rotation and arc. This putter features a super high MOI, forward CG, multi-material head design with our new Stroke Lab shaft, legendary White Hot insert, and tour preferred single alignment line.

View Product

Btw…here’s a great gift

This gift set is everything you need in one box — the perfect gift for anyone who loves hitting the fairways. In the set, you get two Vice Pro Bear golf balls and one golden ball as well as two special edition ball markers and the Vice Gator Gold divot repair tool.