When should you go for it? Top teachers weigh in on par-5 strategy

Welcome to GOLF’s Top 100 Teacher roundtable, where some of the best instructors in the business answer the game’s most pressing questions. The goal? To help your game and lower your scores ASAP.

A common debate among the golf community is whether or not you should go for the green in two on a par-5. Many players believe the risk is always worth it, while others think laying up is the smarter choice. 

The truth is, depending on the situation, both parties are right. You just have to know what factors to consider. 

Fortunately, we have access to top teachers from across the country who can help. With their expert advice and course strategy keys, you’ll learn how to interpret the facts and make the right decision every time.

1. Look at the course layout

Most par-5s are designed with larger greens, which automatically boosts your chances of getting on in two. You also have to consider the shape of the hole and where potential hazards are located. If the green complex and its surrounding areas favor your typical ball flight, that’s a bonus. But, if there are bunkers or water that could catch your fade or draw, it’s best to lay up. – Carol Preisinger

2. Evaluate your odds

I have a 51-percent rule with all of my students. If they believe they have at least a 51-percent chance for success in going for the green, then they should. But success doesn’t always mean sticking it close. For most golfers, a shot that lands on or around the green (within 30 yards) is a successful one. If you’re still on the fence, remember that taking the risk is an excellent opportunity to grow. And regardless of your decision, you’ll learn a lot from the opportunity it presents. – Brady Riggs

3. Stay two steps ahead

According to the stats, the closer you get your second shot to the green, the better your chances are of leaving your third shot inside a closer proximity to the hole. However, if the third shot is difficult for you, it is actually more prudent to lay up. Which is why I tell my students to review the possible outcomes by asking themselves a few questions. If you go for it, where are you most likely to miss it? How tough will that following shot be? Alternatively, if you choose to lay up, what will your third shot look like? How hard will it be to execute that shot? As you answer the questions, be realistic. Don’t just base your choice off of the best possible outcome. – Dale Abraham