This NYC firefighter shaved over 10 strokes by eliminating fat shots. Here’s how

This NYC firefighter couldn't stop hitting fat shots. But here's how he corrected the issue and shaved more than 10 strokes off his game

Can't stop hitting fat shots? Try the same steps this firefighter did to improve his ball-striking!


Welcome to Shaving Strokes, a new series in which we’re sharing improvements, learnings and takeaways from amateur golfers just like you — including some of the speed bumps and challenges they faced along the way.

For anyone who frequently hits fat shots, you know the feeling: one chunk leads to frustration, which in turn can cause all sorts of confidence issues.

That’s because everything can (seemingly) go right in the golf swing, but when it comes to actually making impact with the ball, it just doesn’t go where you expect it to.

That was the problem for a New York City firefighter named John M, who recently tapped golf instructor Eric Cogorno to help correct a common issue: Hitting fat golf shots.

This fatal golf swing flaw is why you keep chunking your iron shots
By: Luke Kerr-Dineen

Says Cogorno: “When John and I first got to the range, he told me, ‘I don’t feel like I know where the ball is going, even though I do swing the club a lot. I feel like I’m trying not to miss.’

“He also said that if he hits a bad shot, he doesn’t know why, which causes him to get panicky because he doesn’t even know what to fix,” adds Cogorno. “Misses make you lose trust and confidence in your process, and it can lead to overthinking mechanics or having negative swing thoughts.”

So Cogorno went to work, spending time with John at the driving range to give him a lesson, restore the confidence in himself, and fix the issues he had with fat shots and pulls once and for all.

Check out the video below and read on for Eric’s tips to understand how he helped rejuvenate the firefighter’s golf game!

Follow these steps to avoid hitting fat shots

John started warming up and hitting shots, and it became very clear that we had two problems to solve.

First, it was trying to figure out why he often hit fat shots and what we could do to fix that. The second issue was trying to have him stop pulling the ball so frequently.

We focused on the fat shots first, since low point control and making solid contact is the most important fundamental in golf. Establishing ball flight or a predicable curve/shot pattern comes after low point control.

Fixing John’s fat shots

While watching John, I noticed that his setup was pretty neutral and centered, with his weight starting at 50/50 in his feet; which is great! From there, there’s always going to be a correlation with where the golfer’s body moves, or their “weight shift,” and where the club is going to hit the ground.

So the more the golfer shifts any part of their body away from the target (towards the trail side), that would increase the odds of them hitting the ball fat. Ideally, John wouldn’t shift so far towards the trail side on the backswing.

This concept also applies during the downswing.

So John had to make sure he shifted his body forward on the way down, meaning more emphasis on the lower body than the upper body. This would make it easier to hit out in front of the ball.

This is the real cause of fat shots, according to cutting-edge golf technology
By: Luke Kerr-Dineen

John shifted a little bit too much away from the target during the backswing, which we simply call “shifting into the trail side.”

When I analyzed the weight in his feet at the top of the backswing, I could see the weight was on the outside part of his trail foot. I would say 80% of his weight was on his trail foot, and maybe 20% was on his lead foot at the top. In a perfect world, to hit the ball more solidly and consistently, I’d look to keep it 50/50 at the top.

You never want the weight to roll to the outside of the trail foot, as there’s no benefit to that. You can keep it on the inside of the trail foot and then really push off that to start down.

Now, since John shifted too much away from the target during the backswing, he had to really make sure he shifted forward enough on the way down. When we compared John to a model swing and looked at the front side of his hip, he didn’t shift forward enough on the way down.

At impact, I’d say his weight was just 50/50 like it was at setup. It should be more forward, say 70/30 or so on the lead side.

So the key takeaway here is that you want to minimize the shift away from the target if you struggle with fat shots.


The reason John pulled to the left was twofold.

Number one was setup related. His shoulder alignment was a little bit too open and pointed to the left.

Number two was his swing path. The club was swinging over the top and too far to the left, which was to compensate for an open shoulder alignment. I also noticed that his hand path was working outward too much during the takeaway.

Brittany Lincicome point pull
Can’t stop pulling the ball? Check on these 2 things, says Top 100 Teacher
By: Jessica Marksbury , Tina Tombs, Top 100 Teacher

We worked on closing John’s shoulders by pulling his trail shoulder back at setup, then neutralized his takeaway to help him swing from the inside more.

Since John went too outside with his hand path during the takeaway, he essentially had to get the butt of the club to hit his trail leg. This cue helped him learn how he needed to feel to find a neutral takeaway hand path.

So the two things that are going to help John fix his pulls are closing the shoulders at setup and having the hand path work further in during the takeaway.


I believe if John just focused on staying more centered in the backswing and shifted more forward on the downswing, that’ll clean up almost all of his fat shots. If he just focuses on closing his shoulders a little bit (just to get them square) and neutralizing his takeaway hand path, that’ll make his swing work from inside, thus fixing his pulls.

By doing both of these things, he should hit really solid, high, tight draws.

Like John, when you’re practicing and changing something in your swing, it has to feel weird and very exaggerated. I then recommend recording your swing in order to make sure that you’re exaggerating enough.

Rukket Sports Pathfinder Impact Mat™

Are you looking for a golf training mat to help your golf game? The Rukket Pathfinder Impact Mat™ was designed with input from professional golfers and golf teachers to help players of all abilities improve their game. The strike mat tracks club face alignment and helps ensure clean contact with the ball while the foam pylons can be used to keep your swing on plane. Use all four pylons to practice hitting straighter shots or remove pylons to practice hitting draw or fade shots. It’s the most versatile golf swing practice mat available and works with every club in your bag! Features 2-in-1 golf swing training mat combining the features of an impact mat / strike mat and a swing path trainer to help golfers quickly identify and correct common swing problems like hooks and slices. It’s a golf swing impact / strike mat to help identify and correct club face alignment. Use the “velvet” turf to ensure you’re making clean contact with the ball. It’s also a golf swing training aid to help with swing plane alignment. Use it to fix a slice or a hook, and to practice hitting draw and fade shots. What’s in the Box (1) Rukket Pathfinder Impact Mat™ (4) Foam Pylons (1) Instruction Booklet Product Specs 25in x 13in x 0.8in RUKKET FAIR PLAY GUARANTEE & LIFETIME WARRANTY: At Rukket Sports we know you came to win. We also understand that in order to win you need to train hard, so that’s why we’re proud to offer the Rukket Fair Play Guarantee & Lifetime Warranty for no-risk purchasing plus outstanding USA-based customer service!
View Product

Nick Dimengo Editor

generic profile image Contributor